Accident-only vs. accident & illness: which do you actually need?
Accident-only is cheap — but it won't pay for the illnesses your breed is famous for. Here's how to choose by breed risk, not by price.
Accident-only covers injuries: broken bones, swallowed objects, bite wounds, torn ligaments from trauma. It typically costs $10–$25/month. Accident & illness adds diseases — cancer, infections, allergies, and crucially, hereditary conditions like hip dysplasia and IVDD. That's the $45–$110/month tier on this page.
The breed rule of thumb
- High-risk breeds (French Bulldog, English Bulldog, Dachshund, Golden, Cavalier): accident-only is a false economy. Their expensive problems are illnesses, not accidents.
- Low-risk breeds (Beagle, mixed breed): accident-only can be a sensible budget floor — their hereditary list is short, and the big surprises are usually injuries.
- Puppies of any breed: illness coverage bought early can never exclude conditions that appear later. That option disappears with age.
One catch: “accident-only” definitions vary. A torn ACL from running is an accident to one insurer and wear-and-tear to another. Check how your provider classifies cruciate injuries before you rely on a cheap plan for an athletic breed.